Over the weekend, you might not have seen the shocking footage coming out of several major Chinese cities, with thousands upon thousands of protesters taking to the streets chanting âstand up,â or âdown with [Chinese president] Xi Jingping.â You may not have seen the rare display of cohesion from the protesters around the same issues of ongoing brutal covid-based lockdowns and government repression. You may also not have paid witness to the repressive and violent shows of force from police and other security forces.
(Warning, potentially graphic content)
WOW!
Watch this brave woman stand strong and continue to film the abuses of Chinese government security forces!
She then gets beaten herself!
While we support the people of Iran, we must also support the brave people of China as they take on the totalitarian CCP! pic.twitter.com/AmCXbdD11t
â Yashar Ali đ (@yashar) November 28, 2022
Why did you not see this? A big reason for Twitter users, at least, was because Chinese-language malicious actors managed to flood the blue bird app with porn links that included the names of the cities involved in the protests. The massively-reduced Twitter struggled to combat what appeared to be government-affiliated accountsâ efforts to dampen news surrounding the protests, according to a report that cites past and current Twitter employees.
According to The Washington Post, Chinese-language accounts started to flood the platform with links to porn services and escorts next to city names. For anybody actively looking for more news about the protests, this would flood their feeds with what amounted to porn ads. The accounts were reportedly dormant for months or years before being activated all at once, according to the Post.
The campaign was confirmed by other China-centric reporters on Twitter who took screenshots of the efforts to screen information about the protests.
Can @elonmusk explain why top search results for these Chinese cities are all escort ads? There have been active protests in these cities and people inside China are coming to Twitter to see what the government has censored. pic.twitter.com/tXQhL2Aoxy
â Wenhao (@ThisIsWenhao) November 27, 2022
One anonymous former Twitter employee told the Post that China-linked accounts have used this tactic before, and that a lot of the work to combat this spam was handled manually. Unfortunately, most of Twitterâs Trust and Safety Team as well somewhere around three fourths of the company were axed in the last month or so, which made responding to the threat harder than in the past. Though an unnamed current Twitter employee said the company identified the threat around midday Sunday, but it wasnât until nearing the end of the day when people on Twitter started to see more protest footage through search results.
Gizmodo reached out to confirm Twitterâs response to the protest misdirection campaign, but the company no longer has much of a press team after CEO Elon Muskâs takeover. We donât expect a response.
Thousands of protesters already stormed the campuses of the Foxconn iPhone factory in Zhengzhou last week. Those workers were reportedly upset that the company apparently lied to contract workers about their pay and two-month timetable, as well as being forced to live in dormitories alongside covid-positive staff. Fortunately, many of those videos spread far and wide on social media despite Chinaâs desperate attempts to curb public information about government protests.
But Twitterâs stalled response to major events was only more apparent this past weekend after freshly-uploaded video of the 2019 Christchurch shooting in New Zealand ended up on the platform. The graphic video showing the terrorist attack where 51 muslim worshippers were shot and murdered was only removed Saturday night going into Sunday after New Zealandâs government gave notice to Twitter. A spokesperson for the New Zealand prime minister told The Guardian that Twitterâs automatic reporting function didnât flag the content when it was uploaded.
The protests were sparked in part by reports that 10 people living in a building under covid lockdown died in a fire last week. There are already reports from the likes of The New York Times of protesters being detained and beaten, so it behooves social platforms like Twitter to keep the lines of communication open, especially noting how much data China already has on its citizens. But with Twitterâs limited safety teams and automatic systems unable to handle fast-moving events from this weekend, it doesnât spell much hope for the future.
